ATC Abstracts

American Transplant Congress abstracts

  • Home
  • Meetings Archive
    • 2022 American Transplant Congress
    • 2021 American Transplant Congress
    • 2020 American Transplant Congress
    • 2019 American Transplant Congress
    • 2018 American Transplant Congress
    • 2017 American Transplant Congress
    • 2016 American Transplant Congress
    • 2015 American Transplant Congress
    • 2013 American Transplant Congress
  • Keyword Index
  • Resources
    • 2021 Resources
    • 2016 Resources
      • 2016 Welcome Letter
      • ATC 2016 Program Planning Committees
      • ASTS Council 2015-2016
      • AST Board of Directors 2015-2016
    • 2015 Resources
      • 2015 Welcome Letter
      • ATC 2015 Program Planning Committees
      • ASTS Council 2014-2015
      • AST Board of Directors 2014-2015
      • 2015 Conference Schedule
  • Search

Legal Status, Criminal History, and Substance Use in Listing Decisions

G. Lee, A. Wall, J. Maldonado, D. Magnus.

School of Medicine, Stanford University, Stanford, CA
Stanford University Medical Center, Stanford, CA.

Meeting: 2018 American Transplant Congress

Abstract number: 388

Keywords: Ethics, Psychosocial

Session Information

Session Name: Concurrent Session: Regulatory Issues

Session Type: Concurrent Session

Date: Monday, June 4, 2018

Session Time: 4:30pm-6:00pm

 Presentation Time: 5:06pm-5:18pm

Location: Room 2AB

Background: Psychosocial criteria constitute absolute and relative contraindications to listing, which can bar patients from access to organ transplantation at a program. Refusing to list patients for psychosocial factors is ethically permissible as long as these factors distinguish those who will benefit most from receiving an organ. Empiric evidence must demonstrate poorer outcomes in patients meeting these criteria before they can be considered contraindications. We conducted a survey study to identify variation in listing practices among transplant programs nationwide.

Methods: We distributed an online Qualtrics survey to 650 active adult and pediatric transplant programs in heart, kidney, liver, and lung from August 2016 to March 2017. The full survey listed 38 psychosocial characteristics, and participants were asked 1) if each characteristic functioned as an absolute, relative, or irrelevant contraindication to listing, 2) whether their program retained formal, informal, or no guidelines regarding the characteristic, and 3) whether their program had encountered the characteristic. This study examines a subset of the 38 characteristics including legal status, criminal status, and substance use.

Results: A majority of programs completed the survey (response rate = 52.8%). Regarding undocumented status, 15- 41% of programs considered undocumented status to be irrelevant (Irr), in contrast to 23-38% that considered in an absolute contraindication (AC). Eight to 26% considered history of violent crime an AC, while 3-12% had formal guidelines for the characteristic. More programs considered recreational marijuana an AC (24-77%) than medical marijuana (12-59%). Compared to heart and lung programs, kidney and liver programs are less likely to consider current substance use an AC (p = <2.2e-16 ~ 0.006). Although more adult than pediatrics programs encountered patients with a criminal history (p << 0.001), 19-47% of pediatrics programs have still encountered these patients.

Discussion: Transplant programs vary in how they consider psychosocial criteria in making listing decisions. Variation in practice violates the principle of equality and invites prejudice into listing process. Further research is needed on post- transplant outcomes of patients with psychosocial criteria so that programs can make evidence-based judgments.

CITATION INFORMATION: Lee G., Wall A., Maldonado J., Magnus D. Legal Status, Criminal History, and Substance Use in Listing Decisions Am J Transplant. 2017;17 (suppl 3).

  • Tweet
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Click to print (Opens in new window) Print

To cite this abstract in AMA style:

Lee G, Wall A, Maldonado J, Magnus D. Legal Status, Criminal History, and Substance Use in Listing Decisions [abstract]. https://atcmeetingabstracts.com/abstract/legal-status-criminal-history-and-substance-use-in-listing-decisions/. Accessed June 6, 2025.

« Back to 2018 American Transplant Congress

Visit Our Partner Sites

American Transplant Congress (ATC)

Visit the official site for the American Transplant Congress »

American Journal of Transplantation

The official publication for the American Society of Transplantation (AST) and the American Society of Transplant Surgeons (ASTS) »

American Society of Transplantation (AST)

An organization of more than 3000 professionals dedicated to advancing the field of transplantation. »

American Society of Transplant Surgeons (ASTS)

The society represents approximately 1,800 professionals dedicated to excellence in transplantation surgery. »

Copyright © 2013-2025 by American Society of Transplantation and the American Society of Transplant Surgeons. All rights reserved.

Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Cookie Preferences